Rational Medicine logoRational Medicinecare · value · evidence
The framework

Highly developed initiatives within global healthcare that, taken together, form a historic movement for medicine as a benevolent human endeavour.

a

Universal healthcare & rational treatment

Healthcare as a community right, built around prevention.

In line with the WHO Alma-Ata declaration — equity, community participation, an intersectoral approach, appropriate technology and a focus on prevention.

Cuba sustains a world-leading health system — ~7.59 physicians per 1,000 — by centring care in the community and the family, with doctors living among the patients they serve.

The Indian subcontinent has decades of community-based rational healthcare: from Gonoshasthaya Kendra in Bangladesh (1972) to Shaheed Hospital in Dalli Rajhara (1983), spreading to West Bengal through the 1990s.

Declaration of Alma-Ata, 1978Gonoshasthaya KendraShaheed Hospital
b

Preventing overdiagnosis & overtreatment

Not every finding needs a label or a pill — 'Too Much Medicine'.

Overdiagnosis is diagnosing a condition that would never have caused symptoms or harm. Driven by fear, defensive practice and disease-mongering, it is among the most harmful and costly problems in modern medicine.

The 2018 Preventing Overdiagnosis conference in Copenhagen (30+ countries) warned that sustainable systems must manage the twin problems of underuse and overuse.

Australia's Wiser Healthcare collaboration targets overuse in mammography, thyroid imaging, back-pain scanning, PSA testing and genetic risk tests — for equity, sustainability and reduced harm.

Preventing Overdiagnosis, Copenhagen 2018Wiser HealthcareCentre for Evidence-Based Medicine
c

A culture of stewardship

Spending limited health resources wisely and fairly.

The NHS Confederation's 'triple value': allocative value (equity across populations), technical value (quality and safety per resource), and personalised value (decisions aligned to individuals).

As high-cost 'precision' drugs flood the market, Ferkol and Quinton (2015) argued society must become outraged enough to insist medicines are sold at a cost it can sustain.

A value-based culture of stewardship is essential for any socially just health system — grounded in social accountability and equity.

A culture of stewardshipPrecision Medicine: At What Price?
d

Rational clinical examination

Good history-taking and bedside skills over reflex testing.

The bedside encounter is central to medicine — the basis of trust, accurate diagnosis and high-value, patient-centred care, and a path to low-cost, high-quality healthcare worldwide.

Stanford Medicine 25, led by Dr Abraham Verghese, revives hands-on physical examination as the essence of diagnosis and healing.

JAMA's Rational Clinical Examination series builds the evidence base for which elements of history and examination actually help reach a diagnosis — reducing unnecessary testing.

Stanford Medicine 25The Rational Clinical ExaminationSociety of Bedside Medicine
e

Evidence-Creating Medicine

Honest evidence, free from Big Pharma's influence.

A wider understanding of the rules of evidence — confronting non-disclosure of trial data, marketing dressed as science, and the limits of narrow corporate-funded RCTs.

Ben Goldacre's Bad Pharma documents how negative trials go unpublished and marketing distorts prescribing; AllTrials (2013) campaigns for every trial result to be reported.

Evidence-Creating Medicine (Richard Bohmer) treats everyday clinical practice as an iterative scientific process. The Rational Medicine Network has already produced two PubMed-indexed papers, free of conflicts of interest.

Bad Pharma — Ben GoldacreAllTrials campaignSTROBE initiative
f

Rational medical education in the AI era

Teaching judgement — and defining the doctor's role beside AI.

Teaching the rationale and evidence base for history and examination, the limits of applying many single-organ guidelines to one real patient, and the irreplaceable role of clinical judgement.

Evidence-based clinical teaching is practical: examination signs can be ranked by reliability (kappa) — wheeze and dullness to percussion (0.52) far outperform whispering pectoriloquy (0.11).

AI tools don't currently save radiologists time and risk overdiagnosis and cost escalation. Technical, allocative and personal value are practically undeliverable without human clinical judgement.

Teaching to address overdiagnosisEvidence-based clinical teachingCost-effectiveness of AI in care
Join the Rational Medicine Network

Help build affordable, sustainable, humane healthcare — for everyone.

Clinicians, physiologists, physiotherapists, nurses, health workers and researchers are welcome. No corporate funding. No conflicts of interest.

Get in touch About the network